Does Car Color Affect Insurance Rates?

A long-standing myth in the automotive world suggests that red cars cost more to insure. It’s an idea that’s been repeated so often, many take it as truth. The thought behind it is simple—red cars look fast, attract more attention from police, and are more likely to be involved in accidents, which supposedly leads to higher insurance premiums. But how accurate is this belief?

In this article, we’ll explore whether car color has any influence on your insurance rates, uncover the real factors insurers use to set premiums, and help you understand how to keep your rates as low as possible.

The Truth: Car Color Does Not Affect Insurance Rates

Let’s get straight to the point—car color has no effect on your auto insurance premium.

Insurance companies do not ask for your vehicle’s color when determining your rate. They base their calculations on many variables, but color isn’t one of them. While it’s understandable why people might think a flashy red car would cost more to insure, this is simply not how insurers assess risk.

Here’s why:

Insurers rely on data, not assumptions. Their underwriting systems use statistical models and historical data to predict risk. These models consider accident rates, repair costs, theft likelihood, and driver behavior—but none of that has any link to the color of the vehicle.
Color is not included in VIN records. The Vehicle Identification Number (VIN) contains details about your vehicle’s make, model, engine type, and features, but not its color. Since insurers use VINs to identify vehicles, color isn’t a factor in their rating systems.

What Actually Affects Your Car Insurance Rates?

If color doesn’t play a role, what does? Here are the main factors insurers look at when calculating your premium:

Factor	Description
Driving Record	Past accidents, traffic violations, or DUI charges raise your rates. A clean record helps reduce them.
Location	Living in an area with high accident or theft rates increases premiums. Urban areas generally cost more than rural ones.
Age and Gender	Young drivers, especially males under 25, tend to pay higher rates due to higher accident statistics.
Type of Vehicle	The make, model, year, safety rating, and repair costs of your car matter. Sports cars cost more to insure than sedans.
Coverage Level	The more coverage you choose—liability, collision, comprehensive—the higher your premium.
Credit Score	In most states, insurers use your credit score to predict risk, with lower scores typically leading to higher rates.
Annual Mileage	More time on the road means a greater chance of accidents, which raises your premium.
Claims History	Frequent claims signal higher risk, which insurers may penalize with increased rates.

None of these criteria include vehicle color, further proving that red, blue, black, or silver cars are treated equally from an insurance standpoint.

Where the Confusion Comes From

The myth that red cars cost more to insure likely stems from a few misunderstandings:

Red Cars Seem to Get More Tickets: Studies have never conclusively proven that red cars get pulled over more. Still, their bold appearance may make them seem like they’re speeding or drawing more attention. This leads to the assumption that red cars are riskier.
Sportier Cars Tend to Be Red: Many high-performance sports cars are painted in red, which may contribute to the confusion. Since sports cars do cost more to insure, people might wrongly associate that cost with the color rather than the type of vehicle.
Psychological Associations: People often link red with aggressiveness and speed. While color may influence how others perceive a car or its driver, insurers do not share this bias when setting rates.

Car Colors and Theft Rates

While color doesn’t affect your insurance rate, some studies have analyzed theft trends related to vehicle color. Thieves may prefer neutral colors like white, gray, or silver, which are more common and less conspicuous. However, insurers don’t directly penalize drivers based on their vehicle’s color, even if certain colors are stolen more frequently.

If your vehicle is a commonly stolen make and model, it may affect your comprehensive insurance rates—but again, this is due to the vehicle type and theft statistics, not its color.

Choosing a Car Color: What Really Matters

While insurance premiums shouldn’t factor into your decision about vehicle color, there are other things to consider:

Resale Value: Neutral colors (white, black, gray, and silver) tend to hold resale value better than unusual colors.
Visibility: Bright colors like yellow or orange may be more visible on the road, which could potentially reduce your risk of an accident.
Maintenance: Dark colors show dirt, scratches, and swirl marks more than lighter shades. Lighter colors may be easier to keep looking clean.

These practical considerations may impact your driving experience and costs in the long term, but again, not your insurance premiums.

Tips to Lower Your Car Insurance Rate

Since color won’t help or hurt you, here are some steps that actually will reduce your premium:

Bundle policies: Combine your auto insurance with renters or homeowners insurance.
Increase your deductible: Raising your out-of-pocket deductible can lower your premium.
Shop around: Compare quotes from different insurers at least once a year.
Drive safely: Avoid tickets and accidents to maintain a clean record.
Take a defensive driving course: Some insurers offer discounts for completing certified courses.
Ask about discounts: Many insurers offer savings for good students, safe drivers, low mileage, and more.

Conclusion

Despite the persistent myth, car color does not affect your insurance rate. Whether you drive a bright red coupe or a navy blue sedan, insurers are more interested in your driving history, where you live, what you drive, and how much coverage you want.

So if you’re shopping for a new car and tempted by a flashy paint job, go for it. Your insurance premium won’t rise just because you chose a bold color. Focus instead on the factors that really matter to insurers—and take steps to be a safer, lower-risk driver if you want to save on your policy.

Read More: